Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | tarpitt's commentslogin

And that needs its own monopropellant rockets in case someone drops it off a cliff

Or you just want it to do a kick flip

Starlink is an interesting option for RVs, but I can't use it because they don't offer static IPs or even ip addresses that aren't behind NAT.

Yes, they do.

https://starlink.com/support/article/1192f3ef-2a17-31d9-261a...

> Starlink offers two IPv4 policies, "default" and "public". The default IPv4 configuration uses Carrier-Grade Network Address Translation (CGNAT) using private address space from the 100.64.0.0/10 prefix assigned to Starlink clients via DHCP. Network Address Translation (NAT) translates between private and Starlink public IPv4 Addresses. Starlink supports native IPv6 across all Starlink routers, kit versions, and service plans. All IPv6 compatible Starlink router clients are assigned IPv6 addresses.

> The Starlink public IPv4 policy is an optional configuration available to Local and Global Priority customers. A public IPv4 is reachable from any device on the Internet and is assigned to Starlink network clients using DHCP. Although truly static IPs are not available, a reservation system retains the public IPv4 address and IPv6 prefix even when the system is off or rebooted. However, relocating the Starlink or software updates may change these addresses. Public IPv4 addresses are available to the Local and Global Priority service plans. The public IPv4 option can be enabled from the account dashboard, see instructions here. Note: Starlink WiFi routers do not support port forwarding or firewall rules for IPv4 or IPv6.

That last bit means you need to use your own router plugged into the ethernet port of the transceiver.

Also, 99%+ of RV internet users get by without static/public IPs, and millions of home internet users do too. I'm a hacker and network administrator, it's not a big deal for me. They give public routable v6 /56 everywhere, so if it's a huge issue for you, you could set up dyndns and use v6, or run an overlay network.


Oh I didn't know that. Yeah I currently only have ipv4 (which sucks) on my residential fiber and have to use dynamic DNS (Their static ipv4 prices are ridiculous). I have exactly the setup you're describing, where I just use the ISP's modem alongside my own router.

Thanks, I'll make a note of this.


What do you use in your RV as an alternative that provides a static IP?

I can't find anything yet. I've considered using LTE as well. Maybe some sort of 5G-based internet plan (like verison) would work, but those are not great value and may be limited to a certain region. I currently just wireguard tunnel to my apartment, but I will eventually have to move out.

If anyone has any ideas I would love to hear. Another similar limitation is recieving snail mail.


Why not use Tailscale?

Why not ZeroTier?

Tailscale has a higher quality application, codebase and backbone, and also more generous free-plan limits.

ZeroTier is FOSS. I can't imagine a reason to use tailscale. If you claim tailscale has a better free model then ZeroTier I take it you run windows.

ZeroTier free: up to 10 devices total

Tailscale free: up to 6 users, each with unlimited devices (used to be 3 users)

I use Tailscale because it's professionally supported and better implemented. It has a much smoother UX compared to ZeroTier. It's also been profesionally audited, while ZeroTier has only sworn since 2020 that it'll totally be audited at some point after 2.0. ZeroTier may be a smaller target, but that also means it has less of a track record.

Also, I don't use Windows, but I don't see how that'd have anything to do with this.


It seems too centralized. At that point why not use a VPS? I have a free vps from oracle I already use to relay some unimportant services to a static IP. But it's extra latency

I also run monerod, p2pool, i2pd and tord nodes, the purpose of which is defeated by central infrastructure.

But yeah friends have reccomended tailscale I have just never gotten fuzzy feelings whenever I revisit it. If we want to build a NAT-less world then everyone needs to get a static ipv6 and run an eepsite or onion service, and we can just use pubkeys for addressing.


Not quite sure what your specific use case it if you've already got a VPS @ OCI (I do too, its great, and super low latency from home to it).

That said, another option not mentioned is cloudflare tunnels. I run cloudflared on a proxmox'd tiny PC. My internal services are accessible to me externally, but secure. Easy to set up the security layer (sign in through your google account, github account, IP restrictions, WARP and lots more).


I'm a long time network admin and Tailscale is my favorite network tool ever. It just magically lets you connect servers in a very secure way. The tools you mention are great for learning but miserable to actually use.

> the purpose of which is defeated by central infrastructure

Any ISP you use will also qualify as central infrastructure. You aren't making any sense. Just rent something that lives in a datacenter and get on with life.


Headscale?

I'll look into this. Thanks.

Connect to a server that DOES have a static public IP address.

My personal experience is that all of my female colleagues have found jobs quite easily (even some pretty unimpressive friends of mine), while all of my male colleagues are struggling to find work. There is a massive hiring bias in favor of women as I understand it.

https://www.cnbc.com/2026/09/04/jobs-report-women-payrolls.h... is a report I've read recently (it's partially due to the growth in the healthcare industry due to aging population). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fFCljh6dBIg&t=144s is a discussion that captures the modern perspective for young men.

The idea that maternity leave plays into this in any signifigant way is totally old-fashioned (in my opinion).

Women essentially have a higher effective charisma thanks to their greater sexual market value. There were some studies that showed women have an in-group bias to support women, but also men have a cross-group bias to support women. People naturally pefer women.


I think the answer is in salary expectations: men have higher average salary. It's easier to find a job if you ask less.

(Hetero) Men need to acquire more wealth instrumentally in order to attract women and raise their children.

One difference there is that's a 9.607% chance of dying after reproducing, whereas for men 10% die (before?) reproducing

I would argue the opposite. Women are born with something that (most) Men want. That puts them at a natural advantage.

We're all here arguing the "hender pay gap", yet women have the single most amazing gift granted to them by the universe that men will never have. What I'd give to be the one to have given birth to my own children.

Care to elaborate? This seems like very obvious double edge sword. We as a society try to mitigate this differences.

There is an asymmetry in the amount of sexual desire between men and women.

The status quo of "sexual liberation" doesn't do much to mitigate this difference. We no longer live in a monogamous society.


Women, likewise, want men. Did you never think of that?

Have you ever spoken with a woman?


I have thought of that. Regardless, there is a pretty obvious discrepancy of supply/demand in heterosexual relationships, which only becomes more evident through my relations with women.

What an absurd, antiquated idea.

This is not at all the case, regardless of your anemic "relations."


( ͠° ͟ʖ ͠°)

nice I might switch to this. I'm just using sway and a couple of gnome things clobbled together

Sure but even electrical power from natural gas or nuke plants is way cheaper than gasoline. Power plants employ massive economies of scale in generation. Even the cost of solar power has fallen dramaticially.

I think in general, a country trying to become industrious and eco-friendly by saving energy is like a person trying to become a millionaire by pinching pennies. Once you have optimized an economic system to eliminate the major cost centers, you're going to have extremely hard time improving it through further cost savings.

For example, If my expenditure roughly matches my income, I would need to eliminate 100% of my expenses just to make enough surplus to match doubling my income. Once I have managed the major cost centers (rent, insurance, etc.) it's not going to be worth my time to further optimize my expendature, the time would be better spent improving my income

For EVs, the fuel cost is already low. The next cost centers are like maintainance, tires, battery life. It would be better to attack these other cost centers or somehow pursue functionality that increases utility of the car.


Just FYI, in some areas of California, served by PG&E, electricity at peak times is $.58/kwh. When gas was around $4.00/gal, it was actually cheaper to use gas in that scenario. (I have a PHEV so I can do either.)

You can get a special account for home charging that lowers that rate to $.32/kwh, and at my work I can charge my car for $.28/kwh. At those rates, and with gas where it is now (typically $5.50 - $6.00/gal) it makes sense to use electric.


Yes it's ridicuous. Many of the charging stations here in PA charge 40c/kwh (my break-even is 30c/kwh). It's not profitable against gas even at these prices. Luckily residential rates are 13c/kwh but it's very inconvenient out here still.


Is that using today’s gas prices?


Yeah I did the math for like 3-4$/gallon, and the efficiency of my car.

It's just ridiculous, there are no charging stations around here and it's like 50/50 chance they charge you some outragous price and have an annoying app or it's completely free to use.


I own a pretty typical phev sedan (Gen 2. Volt), and I use more electricity on my 20 mile commute than the rest of my power usage combined.

All cars just use a ton of power moving a lot of mass. It is actually impressive, it's like 100KW at full tilt. I think i saw someone do the math for how much power transfer you would need to get EV charging as fast as gasoline refuelling: It's in the megawatts.

The only way you could signifigantly reduce power usage of vehicles is to reduce mass dramaticially with a motorcyle or autocycle. The Aptera is an interesting autocycle design based on this line of reasoning, but we are also seeing the emergence of a lot of electric motorcycles.


Yep, having each individual person commuting in their own car is just not that efficient in general. Another data point that amazes me is the NYC subway uses 4-5 million kWh per day. Sounds like a lot until you realize that around 4 million people ride it every day, that’s about 1kWh, or maybe like 20 cents of electricity, per rider. A person commuting 35 miles in an EV would take about 10 kWh daily. They’re never going to beat the efficiency of public transportation.

Also regarding filling up an EV as fast as gasoline, there’s a company in China that has demonstrated charging from 20-80% in 5 minutes. They’re using 3MW charging.

It makes you realize why gasoline has been so popular for so long, you can stop for 5 minutes and dump 500 kWh of energy into your tank. Unfortunately most of that is wasted as heat during the combustion process.


The subway has some great efficiency gains because it's use is so narrow. It can only transport humans and small amounts of luggage, and only goes from point to point with no variability or any real use for transporting any of the materials those people need to survive. You're just dumping the costs off to other areas.

Also, if you factor in the construction, idk what the timeline to pay that off would be.


ok, so then you should also factor in the environmental destruction cause by building roads, the cost of the roads, the environmental cost of burning petrol, the environmental damage of extracting and refining petroleum, and so on.


I thought the comparison was to a BEV, not ICE.


>Also regarding filling up an EV as fast as gasoline, there’s a company in China that has demonstrated charging from 20-80% in 5 minutes. They’re using 3MW charging.

Yeah that's the exact post I saw. I didn't believe the video at the time but I suppose it's possible with enough battery paralellism and cooling.

https://www.thecooldown.com/green-tech/new-ev-technology-cha...


In addition to the Aptera, I think there's a potential market for the enclosed 2-wheel vehicles also like the MonoRacer. The aerodynamic efficiency gains of enclosed cabin motorcycles is huge and greatly improves range, especially at highway speeds. I'd like to see something similar at a lower price range and produced in greater volume.

https://www.peravescz.com/electric-version/


I would like to see more vehicle-to-grid capability out of cars, EVs, Hybrids, and Gas Cars alike.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: