Your first point is a fair one. Although in this situation I think it falls under the "rarely" category, for a few reasons:
- I do architecture, middle-tier, front-end, backend, DBA, devops, and engineering management. I have only met a few people my entire life at my level with all of those skill sets.
- I work an ungodly number of hours and a single new hire is unlikely to be willing to do the same.
- I have a significant amount of proprietary knowledge that while not unusually is very unusual to find in a single person.
I can't say for certain it would take three people but I can say for certain it is either multiple people or one extremely rare person who is going to have a lot of demands and take a long time to find.
And I say this as someone who does hiring. I have interviewed literally hundreds of people.
Per your second point, as I answered previously. I'm not entirely sure the CEO and/or investors wouldn't fund the suite personally. I can't go into detail here on why I feel that way. And even a small chance at a suite is not something I'm willing to risk.
Per your third point, it was more. They have actually paid me back some so I'm optimistic about the rest.
Per your forth point, either its true or they lied and I can't see why they would lie. The team team trusts me and they confide in me. More so they they do with the CEO or even HR. It may not be my problem if they leave but it doesn't bode well for the company.
Edit: as an aside we have had a job listing out for someone to take over just part of my job. We haven't even had anyone apply... and no, I didn't sabotage the listing. HR wrote it.
I had a longer reply but I deleted it because I was here for advice not to defend myself and I would get nothing but terrible useless advice if I lied.
The possibility of your explanation being legitimate is certainly not there. It only makes sense in a world where someone following me out the door is a good thing. And seeing as I have a lot of stock options it is most definitely not a good thing. It is motivation to stay not leave.
I'm sorry you are so jaded you think someone can't be good at their job.
I'm also sorry you apparently live in a world where complaints to HR go unacknowledged. Because at our company they get addressed head on, not buried.
I'll rest easy at night knowing that 7 out of 10 of the developers who left have kept in touch after and thanked me for my mentorship. Something they had no obligation to do. Because if you treat your team right, as I do, and you consistently have their back and mentor them as I do, you don't need to guess if they are telling the truth.
The cases where I wasn't paid, my employer has a written agreement that I am temporarily taking a salary decrease in exchange for a deferred bonus with no date or time limit on the bonus so it's not quite that clear cut.
I'm not a lawyer though, I'm sure if I want to get dirty I could find a way to bend it to my will but I'm not eager to get in the mud, I just want to build great software and get paid a fair salary for it.
From the outside it looks like the owner is using "startup" as a cover to run a consulting shop with significantly underpaid stuff. In any potential liquidity event given the revenue structure and company age it's likely that it pretty much will be valued as a consulting shop with 6 consultants.
We do have products that are made in-house but none that generate even enough profits to cover a single salary.
It didn't start that way. The consultancy came much later as a temporary alternative to shutting down. Unfortunately (fortunately?) it's been successful enough that it shows no sign of being temporary.
But even if he did. I've been careful not to include any answers that don't have plausible deniability and I have changed a few key numbers in such a way that it doesn't change the question significantly.
Edit: even if he did, I think with a few minor exceptions if he read this it gives me more leverage not less.
You obviously don't think very highly of your boss. Anyone who knows you should be able to immediately tell who you are just by writing style and pretension alone.
Not true, I don't think that is obvious at all. In fact, I think very highly of my boss. If I didn't, I would have left years ago. It's one of the things that makes the idea of leaving so difficult.
Second, that is a very specific soft skill that not everyone has. You might have that skill, I don't think everyone does. If I saw my boss' writing I'm very sure I would not recognize it.
Edit: adjectives I've used to describe him in this tread... nice guy, generous, ruthless business person. With the exception of that last one they are positive, and depending on who you talk to, ruthless is a positive word in business.
Well, it is a bet. You can define a time window where you accept the current working terms expecting enough profits/an exit/whatever that give the team better salaries and incentives. You can estimate if this outcome is possible, it is just a dream, or a lottery prize. It would be good to communicate partially or completely your position since it will be irrational to continue in this situation for the long term.
The tax burden on the options would be well more than I can afford. And like you mentioned, my leaving would have a very negative impact on valuation.
My window is 2 years. So at least there is that. Although (not sure if I mentioned that), a bulk of my options came within the last year and I have a 1 year cliff with four years total vesting. So at best 30% of my total options are vested.
Back of napkin math... staying an extra year would be slightly less than 50% more (the second 25% of my largest grant would hit and I'd have half of it).
This is part of what makes the decision so hard. And it's worth noting the valuation of the company is not terrible. If I had this valuation after 4 years I'd be ecstatic. Problem is it's been 7 and I have a lot of sunk cost.
Thank you for the advice. I have tried similar in the past, but I have stopped shy of putting him in a corner.
I have gotten him to agree to let me work on side projects in exchange for the company getting 20%. But I found the hours I need to put into my main job are so long that there is no time left for the side projects (unless I neglect my wife, daughter, and/or my health) so it's an empty promise.
And obviously I can't contract on the side. That would be direct competition.
Taking a step back, it seems like you want to present a perfect solution to your boss that he can just adopt. I mean this in a friendly way, but that's not your job. Your job is to tell your boss what you want. Your boss's job is to figure out how to meet your needs.
Along those lines, I would just tell him politely that you'd like a plan to get your backpay over time, you'd like a raise although you understand that funding may preclude that, and you'd like your non-compete to be altered so at least it doesn't apply to your consulting work, since the scope of the consulting work is so broad that you wouldn't be able to ever get another job. You can mention that given the natural instability of a startup, this fact is stressing you out and making you lose sleep.
I would also ask to "paper" the backpay, so you have more than a verbal commitment on that.
If you talk nicely and respectfully about these issues, it is very likely that he will agree to the one term that doesn't cost him any money. (He will likely stall on all the other terms.)
To clarify: I give it a decent (but still less than 50%) chance of having a reasonable liquidity event. But I give it no chance of having that event before I sink another year or two of opportunity costs into it. It's a decision I weight constantly. And yes, I know I'm probably buying into the Sunk Cost Fallacy.
But I just want to correct one thing. The CEO has generously put a lot of his own money into the company. Nearest I can figure close to (if not over) half his net worth. I don't blame him for not wanting to use his whole net worth. If anything that is part of the issue, he's used his money to lengthen the runway but it hasn't been able to take off. He's also used that as a guilt-trip on me a few times.
Who has the bigger call on you: your wife and daughter, or your ceo? Who is more important? Answer that question, then man up and do what you obviously need to do.
ps -- I'd talk to a lawyer (it's free for a consult! Write down the details so you don't miss anything and can be dispassionate, then ask one or two to review your situation and options!) about filing a wage claim for that $60k, or some other type of compensation.
One last thing. You know what you call people whose leaving would crater a company? Owners. If you're that crucial and only have < 5%, you're a sucker. Sorry man. This is a lesson; don't let it happen again.
My daughter and my wife are certainly doing well but not as well as they can be. It's not like I can't provide for them at $110 per year.
I think I will be talking to a lawyer if I do decide to leave.
And if you think 5% is bad... I negotiated up from 0.5%. I'm not sure I agree that 5% is bad. It is above average for a CTO from what I understand and I'm sure many of those CTOs are just as critical to their companies as I am to mine.
As far as the wage claim... I don't think I can. Technically it is on the books as a deferred bonus. The company paid me minimum wage for that time and I stupidly agreed to it. I'll talk to the lawyer, though.
I disagree. It's simple: if you're crucial to a small company, you're an owner and you get comp like an owner. If you have less than 5%, two options: (1) you're not actually as crucial as you think you are, or (2) you're being ripped off. (Could be some of both!) Buttering up employees and telling them they're crucial is, btw, free. Just like titles. Don't let your boss pay you with free things.
Do you have any numbers or articles I can refer to to back up #2?
There are actually a lot of investors in the company and it raised a fair amount of money before I came on board.
I won't rule out #1. However, I'm basing that assumption on a lot of inside knowledge of how the company works. It's an evidence based assumption not an emotional one. And it's based a lot on how long I have been here and what has come to depend on me. I absolutely 100% do not think I can move to another company and be as irreplaceable, it is a niche I moved into by being the only one who could pick up the pieces when each of the other people left.
Just "staying alive" when you have a major piece of your life invested is a bad situation.
If you are an officer of the company, you should know what your future prospects are. When will you get out of Raman mode? Talk to the CEO, if he does not have a good answer, bail.
Depends on your definition of "ramen mode"... on my salary I can certainly afford more than ramen. (as previously mentioned, I live in an area cheaper than SF)
I'm not sure asking him the plan would help, though. I've been told the plan before only to have us pivot when that doesn't work and essentially reset the clock on the plan.
And yes, I realize how awful that sounds saying it out loud.
- I do architecture, middle-tier, front-end, backend, DBA, devops, and engineering management. I have only met a few people my entire life at my level with all of those skill sets.
- I work an ungodly number of hours and a single new hire is unlikely to be willing to do the same.
- I have a significant amount of proprietary knowledge that while not unusually is very unusual to find in a single person.
I can't say for certain it would take three people but I can say for certain it is either multiple people or one extremely rare person who is going to have a lot of demands and take a long time to find.
And I say this as someone who does hiring. I have interviewed literally hundreds of people.
Per your second point, as I answered previously. I'm not entirely sure the CEO and/or investors wouldn't fund the suite personally. I can't go into detail here on why I feel that way. And even a small chance at a suite is not something I'm willing to risk.
Per your third point, it was more. They have actually paid me back some so I'm optimistic about the rest.
Per your forth point, either its true or they lied and I can't see why they would lie. The team team trusts me and they confide in me. More so they they do with the CEO or even HR. It may not be my problem if they leave but it doesn't bode well for the company.
Edit: as an aside we have had a job listing out for someone to take over just part of my job. We haven't even had anyone apply... and no, I didn't sabotage the listing. HR wrote it.