Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | throwawayfifo's commentslogin

Debian's ancient packages and kernel.


>As a tactic though it's a bit like tracers, they work in both directions.

False. You cannot see who downvotes your posts.


>Essentially there's an asymmetry, because companies going bankrupt have no liability for debts

That's not what a limited-liability company is, not what it means. Anthropic and OpenAI are not LLCs.

>So the risk of bankruptcy is still covered by the general public, but a lot less of the benefits are felt by the public.

That's not how any of this works. Reading comments like this on HN and from elected officials is disappointing.


You're talking past the OP commenter. Not all companies whose owners enjoy the benefits of limited liability are Limited Liability Companies (LLCs). The other commenter was discussing the general concept of a company whose owners enjoy limited liability, meaning they cannot be held responsible for the company's debts or other financial obligations beyond the value of their ownership stake, i.e. their _liability_ for the company's obligations is _limited_. There are many corporate forms that provide this benefit to their owners, including common US corporate structures like LLCs, C Corps, S Corps, and Limited Liability Partnerships (LLPs). It's important to note that the terminology varies across jurisdictions, so the specific structure we call an LLC might be called something else entirely or might not exist at all.

Which is precisely why the OP commenter framed their argument in terms of the general concept of limited liability. The argument applies to any company structured with joint ownership and limited liability, whether we happen to label that corporate structure C Corp, Private Limited Company (Ltd.), Gesellschaft mit beschränkter Haftung (GmbH), or even Limited Liability Company (LLC).


>You're talking past the OP commenter.

No I'm not. The OP clearly doesn't understand the basic concepts. "Because companies going bankrupt have no liability for debts" is misunderstanding what "limited liability" means.

>Which is precisely why the OP commenter framed their argument in terms of the general concept of limited liability.

That's not the general concept of limited liability. They are simply mistaken. They just parroted Reddit and BlueSky takes.


I hope this doesn't sound rude, but I think you've interpreted my point in the least charitable way possible.

Non LLC are not unlimited liability companies. Those have existed historically, and mean that owners themselves are legally on the hook for any company debt, without limit.

Since I'm trying to repeat back something I heard elsewhere, I'll link to the original discussion. Adrian Wooldridge is a long term writer for Bloomberg and not sine random guy on a soapbox. The discussion is well thought out, and not emotionally charged. Sorry if I've accidentally given a different impression.

https://www.pushkin.fm/podcasts/business-history/how-the-com...


For this argument, is there a meaningful difference between a PBC and an LLC?


There are many meaningful differences, from corporate structure to ownership and tax classifications. For example, LLCs cannot issue private stock to shareholders. PBCs are effectively C corporations[0], but with bylaws that include making a positive impact on society (not just maximizing profit)[1].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C_corporation

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefit_corporation


Hope it's not stored in a Ledger wallet...


Why, because you read a single Youtube title that said ledger got hacked, that you didn't even watch and dont know the specifics?

Sorry, the likelihood of my banking creds, or other important accts getting hijacked via an infostealer or some other method is about 100x more likley than me buying a tampered ledger device.

A hardware supply chain attack is easily mitigated by inspecting your hardware and buying from a reputable source and not a singular random malaysian shopify site selling hardware wallets...


Because everyone knows how to inspect hardware against future supply chain attacks, right?


>Why, because you read a single Youtube title that said ledger got hacked, that you didn't even watch and dont know the specifics?

No, because there was global news and retailers in Germany taking devices off the shelves:

https://x.com/0xJohannes_/status/2109240472933671125

https://www.heise.de/en/news/Crypto-thieves-sell-hardware-wa...

>Sorry, the likelihood of my banking creds, or other important accts getting hijacked via an infostealer or some other method is about 100x more likley than me buying a tampered ledger device.

Sorry, the likelihood of my banking creds, or other important accts getting refunded via any bank or some other method is about 10000x more likley than me getting my buttcoins back.

>A hardware supply chain attack is easily mitigated by inspecting your hardware and buying from a reputable source and not a singular random malaysian shopify site selling hardware wallets...

People bought compromised devices from reputable sources and still lost all their buttcoins.


Ive been hearing the same cope since 2016, bud. Its so tiring.

Im not saying its for everyone, its definately not for normies like yourself

Ive had more money stolen, and not refunded in traditional bank accounts (thousands) than Ive ever had stolen in crypto (none).


>I wonder how soon someone will leave a comment here saying something like, “Aaactually, this isn’t censorship.”

Is there something wrong with commenting that factual statement? This is objectively not censorship.


Here you go )


There facts go )


You guys do everything in your power just to avoid calling a spade a spade. What you call “facts” is really just juggling terminology and devaluing meanings. Honestly, I just don't understand what's stopping you from simply admitting that you just like censorship - that's a valid point, and I can respect that. So why don't you just say so? Huh?


This is the opposite of "such cases." The Trump administration is doing exactly what he was democratically voted in to do by the "Don't Tread on Me people": close the border and deport illegal immigrants.


That's not relevant to him spying on political enemies.


Thanks Obama! That's not relevant to him doing what he was democratically elected to do.


>Meanwhile in Europe it's near universal

False: https://stats.labs.apnic.net/ipv6


On HN, 'In Europe' means in one person's particular locale based on their experience and generalised across a continent of about 30 countries. But it's always better than in the US of course.


Can we stop this europe/us fight? This remark was completely unwarranted


I wrote this as a European (British) who is living in another European country (Finland). People happily write ‘in Europe’ whilst being quite selective in their definition of Europe - usually their very close neighbourhood, and it usually means North and Central Europe. If that.

I’ve seen some truly unhinged takes here, my favourite ever being something along the lines of European cars not having cup holders because we don’t have drive-throughs in Europe… I have driven my Volkswagen across this continent and enjoyed many a hot beverage on the move.

I’ve come to learn that discussions on a lot of things, in English, usually end up as a comparison to the States, especially if it involves the healthcare sacred cow.


Downvote me more for trying to be peaceful, redditors


The entire premise of this article is based on fake news.

Starshield != Starlink. One is controlled by the US government, one is controlled by SpaceX/Elon.


>Just ban frats, they serve no useful purpose related to a university's goals.

Sororities also serve no useful purpose related to a university's goals. Ban both.


A basic Honda civic now costs $25,000 in the US.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: