Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | totalhack's commentslogin

Carbon has been slow, but excellent at deep dive analysis of some of my projects, finding optimizations other models missed AND explaining them in a clear and concise manner, even as the conversation develops and really becomes four or five subthreads on the opportunities that it brought up. Maybe that massive context window helps.

I use the Local harness in vs code with a GitHub copilot max plan. Gives access to the best models from OpenAI and Anthropic (I use 6.1 sol, Astra, and opus 5.5 for most things). The Local harness has granular keep/undo and nice interface in general for reviewing changes, which is important for mission critical code. Unfortunately the copilot team is trying to force the less capable, more YOLO-mode "copilot" harness on people going forward. The community is somewhat getting them to walk that back but they seem to be missing the mark on what differentiates their product until people complain.

I also use chatgpt desktop for some tasks through a chatgpt teams/business plan. I briefly tried to set up codex cloud and it was a mess, not following startup instructions so I gave up.


Gemini 3.7 may have fast token output but holy cow does it waste it on useless output. Several times now I've given it a shot and watched it's reasoning trace go through a bunch of unnecessary / off-target steps relative to what I asked. Don't have this issue with 5.6 models. MAI Code 1.1 is also solid and fast for non-complex tasks.


What is the latency you are seeing with 5.4 no reasoning? And where have you landed for stt and tts solutions?


The tiring part for me is the waiting and/or context switching to fill that time. When agents of this intelligence or better can get you results in seconds instead of minutes we can start thinking single threaded again and it will be more enjoyable.


If you are talking about the Copilot built into vs code, that's not been my recent experience at all. Very capable in agent mode since gpt 5.4 came out.


Especially since gpt 5.5 it's on par with Opus 4.7 or Sonnet.


It's optional, and that's great, because its necessity or benefit is situational.


Agree with this, though I've mostly been using Gemini CLI. Some of the simplest things, like applying a small diff, take many minutes as it loses track of the current file state and takes minutes to figure it out or fail entirely.


I use markdown files in vs code. Supports folding of sections, combined with a few keyword/char patterns that I highlight different colors. Also get code highlighting in properly labeled code sections.


Did you find out what service he was using?


It sounds like an answering service like Rosie (no affiliation): https://heyrosie.com/


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: