I agree that a lot needs to change about the H-1B program, but I don't love how much of it has come from executive orders and worse: just offhand statements that drive employers into anxiety and uncertainty. Uncertainty is just the worst thing for the market (and my own salary prospects). The $100,000 fee felt like it was rolled out in jolts. Who was affected? Who was exempt?
At least with laws passed, we see it coming from a long way away. IMO, congress should reduce the powers the executive branch can just wield on this or that, and set the agenda, rather than letting the agenda be set by the president every 4/8 years.
You gotta take a civics class. You cant move fast and break things with legislation. The precendent of the executive branch disturbing the balance of power by making laws and policy like this is not worth the benefit of this one issue being expedited. We need to have congress solve this problem because that maintains the balance of power
Civics class isn’t going to make Congress functional. The evidence is the executive branch can do a lot of what it’s done, and if Congress does nothing, there are no consequences for doing so.
Balance of power only exists if you allow it to, if you have power. If you can’t be or aren’t bound by a counterbalance, there is no balance of power, its honor system.
Congress has had over two decades to fix this. They haven’t. Someone else did.
I think you’re the one who needs a civics course. These are powers vested in the executive since this country’s inception, and this is hardly the first time they have disturbed the “balance of power”, especially when almost every EO this administration has put out has been judicially challenged at every point, whether the challenge had actual legal standing or not.
I agree that congress should speak on this (and codify more strict immigration laws), but EOs are only enforcing the powers within the executive branch, not creating new laws. When they restrict an agency’s abilities or empower them, these are simply internal orders within the executive branch, in large part because no singular law or laws govern agencies and defines their explicit day-to-day. EPA, DEA, and NSA are all examples of executive-led agencies made without explicit law codifying their creation. And, such as with H1B, even when the legislation created it the laws are loose enough to give the executive full legal control without disturbing anything from a civics perspective.
Congress spoke in ‘52 and set the ceiling. Executive speaks today and tells you how that ceiling will be reached, if at all. Judicial speaks tomorrow and ensures that orders from today follow the rules from ‘52, and due to the current laws they do.
Because Nvidia is personally investing in a huge amount of those customers, enabling the hyperscaling. If half of the circle breaks, the other half does too.
And those customers still have the demand to keep wanting more.
Contrary to the AI-bubble-doomsayers - most hyperscalers and neoclouds seem to be at capacity for current demand and even have already booked future demand.
That's... really wild. I'm amazed at how the characterization is basically a lie. I go to Planet Fitness where there are 10 TVs with different channels in a row and sometimes all the networks have the exact same story in the exact same light within minutes with each other. It's almost creepy how lockstep they are.
It's state dependent, but many states have no threshold. If you visit that state to attend a conference and you're on the clock or you do some work in an airport terminal during a layover, you need to files taxes in that state. Nobody has likely ever been pursued for this type of short term event, but they could.
> If you visit that state to attend a conference and you're on the clock or you do some work in an airport terminal during a layover, you need to files taxes in that state.
Please provide an example of a state with this policy - I've worked for giant corp that track city-level travel for taxation purposes and have never seen a situation where an employee had to file an out of state return for a conference or a one day trip.
In New York, for example, if you are there for less than two weeks your employer doesn't have to withhold taxes but the you must file a NY return and pay state taxes.
Your employer is keeping track of where you are working to cover their obligations. You are still ultimately responsible for your obligations. Any tax software will help you with this. TurboTax, for example, will ask if you made money in any other states last year.
Your new york link is terribly inaccurate (no surprise as it's trying to sell compliance services). The requirement does not apply to "some work in an airport terminal during a layover" - it applies to income from New York sources - per the state of New York's own website:
I feel I fall into two camps for different projects. I have a hobby project where I'm writing native UI components by hand without AI, and managing memory in an Arena allocator I wrote myself. I also have a hobby project where I honestly don't touch the code, I just think in terms of systems run per frame and the time complexity of different algorithms, making Claude do it. Most personal projects are somewhere in between. I don't think either approach is insane, immoral, or any other hyperbole.
> I don't think either approach is insane, immoral, or any other hyperbole.
Agree! To me it comes down to intention and attention.
Depending on my *intention*, I should devote more or less of my *attention* to one thing vs another.
Another way to think about it is essential vs incidental attention, which I borrow from essential vs incidental complexity [0].
Many things require attention, or it doesn't perform correctly. Essential attention. Many, many more things don't require my full attention, and they'll still perform adequately. They satisfice.
Farm out the tasks that require only incidental attention.
Thanks for the link. Software is all about managing complexity. I like the point about testing and external reasoning. LLMs can write a lot of tests in short order, many of which don't do much to help the program. It enjoys "pinning" behavior, which is basically just confirming a golden path and doing nothing to actually examine the behavior of a module under various conditions.
If you're working on a CRUD/web app, absolutely. There's so much data for web apps out there that LLMs now produce better web app code than most of my coworkers from 2022 or so, since it follows consistent style rules. Web app code all looks the same, anyway.
To be fair, overpopulation was never an actual concern. Since the 1800s, food production growth rates have outpaced population growth rates. Underpopulation _is_ a concern when infrastructure and social structures may not be able contract quickly enough to sustain our current quality of life.
As long as the population depends on non-renewable resources, technically any population size is overpopulation. With the technology we currently use our population levels can't be sustained for very long.
You can see all the bad things about modern cultivation but lack of resistance to climate change isn’t one.
Yes, for many swaths and types of traditional agriculture and fishing it will be doom, but this conversation isn’t about local ecosystem but global food production vs population growth.
Food production was never a problem, supply and management is.
Do you know why and how food production has been able to match population growth and how long much more it can scale? We are using almost all of earth's farmable land right now.
Not through farming a larger area of land, that's for sure. It's been mostly up to improvements in crops, nitrogen fixing, the invention of the reefer car, and other things.
Additionally, I'd like to remind you that we have a lot of wiggle room: if we stop growing alfalfa and stop doing stupid things like biofuel, that will free up an enormous amount of land.
While nearly half of all habitable land is used to some extent as agriculture, the total amount of land in active cultivation has actually been declining since the early 2000's and we currently abandon more farmland every year than we clear forest or convert to agriculture. Between 1992 and 2020, ~ 7% of all cropland was effectively 'abandoned' and much of the production capacity in the west is actually intentionally kept from being fully planted in order to control against overproduction of cereal crops which in the past has been justified by arguing that this control is necessary to prevent market crashes when distribution networks cannot absorb the full capacity of a harvest.
Globally, there are about a billion acres, 400ish million hectares, ~ about half the size of Australia, which sits unused according to FAO satellite and other observables datasets.
About half of the abandonment not due to cultivability at the simplest level, but rather that of transportation of the crops to market or of access to workforce (labor or equipment) to the land. Smaller, more distant crops without significant mechanization simply cannot compete at the prices possible through mechanization. With a lack of access to global niche markets and the higher prices for, say, premium organics, many successive generations of farming families have simply moved to town and left the land sitting, unused.
The other ~ half of abandoned land is because of degraded production capacity through mismanagement; either through over-application of petrochemical fertilizers instead of crop rotation, or through mechanized tilling without careful erosion management. Many farms have neither the time nor the resources (or in the case of large industrial operations the long-term financial foresight on the part of management) to engage in multi-year regenerative practices necessary to reestablish the soil mycostructure and probiotic ecosystems necessary to recover productivity.
However, if demand were to rise sufficiently and if production instead of distribution was the driving force behind food scarcity, we do indeed have arable land reserves which do not require further destruction of uncultivated wilderness to meet a growing demand.
There is actually an inverse relationship to land productivity at scale; the larger farms do extract more gross tonnage of product at lower costs of per-unit equipment and labor, but actually those operations significantly underproduce volumes of harvestable food if measured in 'per unit of land' instead of labor hours. Fields with multi-level, interconnected plant communities significantly overproduce in terms or total volume. This has been demonstrated in nearly every place on earth using very simple techniques that have varied names and different approaches to marketing, but are all very much the same thing: call it Fukuoka's "One Straw Revolution", Bill Mollison's "Permaculture", Historic Food Forests in Africa and the Decca in India, or in the Middle East "Oasis". In the Americas it still is "Three sisters" gardening. These techniques simply are not mechanized and delivering mass volumes of single commodity product into a global distribution network and that's where the difficulty and disconnect between global populations and available nutrition originates.
If there was a technological and market incentives to connect abundant and diverse harvests in rural communities with Bodegas, restaurants, and grocery store chains in the big cities without ten middle-men adding cost for the consumer without improving the product in the least, then half of the land abandonment issue could unwind and small farms could thrive, not by delivering bulk raw indistinguishable commodity to food manufacturing, but by delivering farm fresh produce to kitchens and fruit stalls.
If that were both low-cost for the consumer, and high earning for the farmer while having quality control and assured provenance then the conversation could center around making better use of even less total cropland and restoring wilderness to a near-native sustainable state.
But as it stands now, we're not short on crop land to human population ratio so much as short on effective distribution and incentives for responsible production.
/todays-soapbox
... this is kind of my area of peculiar skill and work. I've tried to steer multinational, multimillion Euro/dollar agriculture operations that produce significant volumes of global "organically produced" harvests in the direction of cooperating with rural and indigenous farming communities in conserving soil health to the benefit of all. That's been a mixed bag, so the forward momentum is with the local rice production in rural Yamagata. Same objectives, more cooperation and long term planning.
I think these are very fun and I would love to see more content you can visit with curl. I'm setting up a home chores + calendar + weather station that runs off my homeserver. I was contemplating making a plaintext version so very stupid devices could still read and display interesting data.
> Can this be gamed? Teaching the AI to write less like stock Claude and stock ChatGPT? Yes, absolutely. And honestly that would be great. Because half of the irritation is that all these AI-written article sound the same!
At least with laws passed, we see it coming from a long way away. IMO, congress should reduce the powers the executive branch can just wield on this or that, and set the agenda, rather than letting the agenda be set by the president every 4/8 years.
reply