Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | zdp7's commentslogin

Da Red goez fasta. Hence the router beats the non red router to the punch.


No Valve system is console like. The PC / Console difference has always been that consoles are a walled garden. Consoles are PCs to be easy to use and not allow unauthorized software to run on it.


> No Valve system is console like.

That entire paragraph makes it obvious that I'm talking about hardware. From the first sentence that spells it out, to talking about upgrading RAM. On the software front, the "open" PC ecosystem is heading in a bad direction for consumers too. So what if I can install from any store if they all rent me the same game at the same price? The difference between Valve and Epic is that one has a loyal following of promoters but in the end I don't own the game, I'm only renting it. And we're always one step away from rentseeking and or losing access even to those rentals.


It's not though. We get the machine code for programs we run on our PCs. All the logic is provided to the end user. The only protection these days, is not doing all the game logic on the end users PC.


They don't organize over Instagram. One of many social accounts had issues. Around 3000 communities participated. They are doing fine.


I had been using Gemini to build OpenScad models. The other day Gemini mentioned CadQuery as an option. It's essentially OpenScad for Python. The big plus is b-rep modeler.

https://github.com/cadquery/cadquery


It's not though. Passkeys are meant to allow you to have multiple. They also don't need to replace passwords. Take my bank setup. I have a password, a windows passkey and an android passkey. I saved the time needed to setup the passkeys, the very first time I used them. The passkeys are easier to use, than my password, and more secure.


It breaks the traditional login paradigm. I had a hard time trying to setup a single device as my passkey manager. Now I realize that you should make one on all your devices. My bank website, I have my password and two separate passkeys. Individual sites may have an implementation issue, but in that case I use the more troublesome password workflow. I still come across password implementation issues on some sites.


Interesting. I still want to be able to login if all my devices are stolen/destroyed. Guessing people will be in pickles after natural disasters.

Good tip!


I still can use my password. I use the passkeys for the convenience and extra security. If I lost all my devices I would just login with my password and add a new passkey. I would also remove any for devices that I don't control or are damaged. I suspect even if the site were passkey only, they would have some account recovery workflow.


The thing the people are also sometimes missing is that I leave my YubiKey at home... especially in those situatiosn where I am prone to lose it.

Going to a concert - I'll take my phone but not my YubiKey, etc.pp

And if I enroll 2 YubiKeys, I can deposit one safely at home. I want my phone to be less important, not more important.


Passkeys are always more secure.


Password managers provide all the same security benefits as passkeys, without the lock in.


Absolutely not. Phishing resistance is the big one. But also if hardware backed, resistant to stealers.


Password managers give you phishing resistance, and most passkey storage is not hardware backed.

In typical scenarios, passkeys offer no advantages over a password manager.


I might not be as thorough as others on here in my password manager setup, but I don't think my password manager setup is as phishing resistant as passkeys.

Fairly frequently, I find myself searching for the password manager entry I want, and copying the username or password.

For a while, I was very consistent in trying to fix the URLs for that password manager entry, every time it happened. But when I'm on mobile, sometimes it's just a pain.

There are quite a few scenarios - I'm logging into an app, and it doesn't use a browser window for authentication, but also logs out after a few weeks, I've been redirected to Microsoft or similar for the login, but I haven't added microsoft.com as a URL for my work login, or GitHub (I could be wrong about this example), etc.

When I list them, these reasons seem like I should have solved them already. I used to try to keep my password manager tidy, but when I'm at 674 entries and it's growing faster than I'm cleaning.

I also think Passkeys are a confusing mess, and I don't mind the idea in addition to a password/TOTP option, but definitely not instead. I do like having it as an option for Google, where I have occasionally encountered a scenario where I login from overseas, and can't login despite having everything they can possibly want (username, password, backup email, etc.). I can't remember the exact details now, so I hope I'm not being uncharitable to Google's login/lockout process, but I doubt it!


> There are quite a few scenarios - I'm logging into an app, and it doesn't use a browser window for authentication, but also logs out after a few weeks, I've been redirected to Microsoft or similar for the login, but I haven't added microsoft.com as a URL for my work login, or GitHub (I could be wrong about this example), etc.

I don't exactly understand what you mean but it seems more like a problem with the auth token.


No. Password managers cannot prevent you from manually copying and entering a password. With passkeys, however, you don’t enter a password; instead, you receive a "challenge" generated by using your passkey public key, which you then solve using your passkey private key. The exact same principle used for SSH keys and with SSH nobody would argue to use password authentication over SSH keys. Of course, this doesn't stop someone from stealing your private key, or from having Claude explain how to export that key from a digital wallet and enter it into a phishing site (and yes, of course there will always be people willing to go to such lengths if it’s the only way to gain access because why wouldn't they). Still, the hurdles are significantly higher than they would be with a standard password. Ideally, you should bind your private key to a hardware security key (such as a YubiKey or Nitrokey) or to an (of course inherently malicious and absolutely despicable) TPM module, which effectively ties the key to a specific PC. In that case, neither you nor an attacker with root privileges would be able to export the key.


They offer advantages but it’s anyone’s guess if the sites you use them with use most of them sanely.

1. In practice everything that saves a passkey requires a biometric to unlock each time, so you SHOULD not be required to use another factor (the secret is “something you have” and the bio is “something you are.” In practice though, now every F—-ing site insists on the damn “we emailed you a code” BS.

2. Passkeys certainly don’t need to be changed every arbitrary period like some idiotic sites (or IT admins) insist for passwords.

3. If one becomes compromised, you can revoke just the one. Unlike a password.


The typical scenario for majority of users unfortunately does not include a password manager, passkeys are a huge step up from that.

For the people already using password managers, it's not a huge step to get a Yubikey and use that for hardware-backed passkeys.


The fact that I can't get passkeys to work like 10% of the time makes me think they're significantly more secure. If I can't use them to access my account, an attacker definitely won't be able to /s


Can you login using a password on an untrusted PC and be sure it's still safe? And there is no lock in. You can have multiple passkeys from different providers I have Windows and Android setup for my bank. The lock in conspiracy doesn't even make sense. Who benefits. Let's just say Google tried to only allow passkeys. Why is my bank going to drop passwords and enter into passkey only relationship with Google and/or Apple. If I have that power I am not going to use a web standard anyone can implement. I would use a proprietary system that nobody else can.


It's the Walmart Effect at internet speeds.


The public isn't saying anything of the sort. Police are buying them or cities. It's justified by telling us it makes us safer, but it's not. Let's be honest, if you have a license plate number, the alpr system probably isn't that useful. Criminals steal cars and license plates. Immigrants and activists don't.


This is your bubble. The mayor of my city had a video up with the Police chief with a Flock camera between them talking about how this will help with the "recent traffic crime wave".

Meanwhile the police say (and act) that they aren't legally required to protect you [1].

The public is screaming for solutions, today you'll scream back at Flock, tomorrow there will be another "solution".

[1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2005/06/28/politics/justices-rule-po...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: