Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | zero_k's commentslogin

John Berger is amazing, and his "Seventh Man" (title based on an amazing Hungarian poem) is IMO his best work (and 2nd best is "A Fortunate Man: The Story of a Country Doctor")

"To try to understand the experience of another it is necessary to dismantle the world as seen from one's own place within it, and to reassemble it as seen from his. For example, to understand a given choice another makes, one must face in imagination the lack of choices which may confront and deny him. The well-fed are incapable of understanding the choices of the under-fed. The world has to be dismantled and re-assembled in order to be able to grasp, however clumsily, the experience of another. To talk of entering the other's subjectivity is misleading. The subjectivity of another does not simply constitute a different interior attitude to the same exterior facts. The constellation of facts, of which he is the centre, is different."

(from A Seventh Man)


Incredible quote, deserves multiple reads

Habermas talks a lot about the coffeehouses in his "The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere" -- how they changed the way society functioned, and politics was discussed and formed by them.

``` However much the Tischgesellschaften, salons, and coffee houses may have differed in the size and composition of their publics, the style of their proceedings, the climate of their debates, and their topical orientations, they all organized discussion among private people that tended to be ongoing; hence they had a number of institutional criteria in common. First, they preserved a kind of social intercourse that, far from presupposing the equality of status, disregarded status altogether. The tendency replaced the celebration of rank with a tact befitting equals. The parity on whose basis alone the authority of the better argument could assert itself against that of social hierarchy and in the end can carry the day meant, in the thought of the day, the parity of ‘common humanity’ (‘bloss Menschliche‘). Les hommes, private gentlemen, or die Privatleute made up the public not just in the sense that power and prestige of public office were held in suspense; economic dependencies also in principle had no influence. Laws of the market were suspended as were laws of the state. Not that this idea of the public was actually realized in earnest in the coffee houses, the salons, and the societies; but as an idea it had become institutionalized and thereby stated as an objective claim. If not realized, it was at least consequential. ```


Doesn't Habermas associate the coffeehouses with the rise of the bourgeoise to become the dominant class in the 18th and 19th centuries. The coffeehouses enabled the formation of a public that was beyond the control of the church and the nobility, which had been predominant before and after the Peace of Westphalia respectively.

Habermas and his Coffeehouses https://medium.com/whither-news/habermas-and-his-coffeehouse...


Sounds similar to anonymous internet forums around the mid 2000s until the mid 2010s

Or coffeehouses from the 1960s to the 1990s.

Anonymity, the unique feature of early internet forums, was also a great leveler of the intellectual playing field that allowed people to share ideas irrespective of the "status" of who they were talking with.

What sort of happened was that status has a way of taking over those spaces, or else they become flooded with noise.

I've noticed over my life that it's difficult to find a space to talk and collaborate with peers for any length of time before it's somehow hijacked, if it had any value to begin with. This seems to be the way of the world.


Yes, either this or it becomes an elitist club focused on exclusion.

The only way I have found around this is to actively moderate those spaces, but even then it depends on the moderator.


I'd love to have one that randomly fails, so we could debug e.g. databases and other apps that are supposed to be resilient. I'd call it "havocfs". Doesn't corrupt data, just randomly fails reads/writes/etc. Some software is supposed to handle that gracefully. Would be a great test tool...



Such a filesystem could be done with FUSE. Devices can be done by Linux itself: https://docs.kernel.org/admin-guide/device-mapper/dm-flakey....


I feel the pain. We have been delaying release because sooo many bug reports have come in. AI is finding a lot of obscure, and interesting, and annoying bugs.


Thanks, I tried :)


LOL I love this and also hate it. You are the best and also the worst. I am actually laughing :D Who cares about deepening our understanding? Curiosity? Hoping to understand some deeper connections/meaning? Let the AI write 10 papers to top conferences per year, and be done with it. If this is what people think science is, that's what we should do. Incentives -> outcomes, in the purest form. Loving it. And hating it!


Yes, the proxy (here, papers & citations) becomes the goal, and so we end up in strange places :(


Fair, but I just don't know how to fix it. Eventually, whatever metric you come up with, it will be gamed -- p-hacked, if you will. Not sure what the solution is. I am just dissatisfied with whatever is going on, and I felt like sharing it. Maybe you have some good ideas? It'd be nice to fix this...


You'd have to look at the US constitution: set groups against each other. Off the top of my head you have the 3 groups of Researchers, Referees/Publishers, Grant Funders

Referees/Publishers are set against Researchers, in, I dunno here, that their incentive is to make sure the researchers are wrong in some little way.

Researchers are set against the Grant Funders. Like, maybe you have to elect them somehow?

Grant Funders are set against the Publishers in that they select journals for funding. Look, it's Monday morning, I'm grasping at straws here, alright?

Anyways, take whatever many groups you have, at least 3 for proper roshambo mechanics, and set their incentives against each other, round and round, and such that at the end, you have 'Science' spinning towards greater public service.


FWIW, I thought that initial quote was very relevant but was also glad you didn't waste a paragraph explaining what everyone knows, that over-emphasizing publication and citation counts and grant money raised is killing academic research. I don't have good ideas either. In the age of AI, cheap metrics and metric hacking are only going to become more prominent.


I'm sad to hear that. I know of a PhD student who confided in me that his professor didn't believe his suspicion that the results of a well-known, supposedly top tool, are wrong. According to his view, not being able to replicate or improve that tool has prevented him from being allowed to graduate. While I cannot confirm this, I suspect there to be a grain of truth in the story. The results are indeed wrong, but I suspect the results are too big to fall -- too many people made too many mistakes (reviewers, editors, awards committees, hiring committees, etc.). It's sad.


It's a fine line. Fraud? No, they are just sloppy, and so one questions whether they ought to be amended, retracted, or a note by the editor attached. The solution you propose, about a follow-up paper is that who will accept a paper that simply demonstrates that the original work was so full of bugs/issues/misconceptions, that many/most of the claims of the paper don't hold? Would you accept that paper into a top-rated conference? And if it's in a 2nd or 3rd rate conference, wouldn't most people question it authenticity (remember, 2nd and 3rd rate conferences have less rigor in reviews) or simply not hear about it? I think these are legitimate concerns.

A slightly sad side-effect of the follow-up-paper idea, is that it sometimes means that the authors get one more citation, and furthermore, since some of the authors may themselves write part of it, it would mean even more papers by the authors, potentially further cited. So we may be unfortunately incentivizing sloppy research -- the authors can now make two papers: one sloppy, and one fixed. Not sure that's great.

I am not saying what you are proposing is wrong. But it has side-effects that are not great.


What’s the difference between sloppiness and fraud when you stand behind the paper all the same? I would argue that sloppiness in academia is a form of fraud. It’s one thing to be bad at writing, and another to have poor methodology


An honest researcher who has made a mistake on a matter of substance will seek to correct the scientific record, even at a cost to their reputation. Not doing so breaches professional ethics and is arguably worse than plagiarism, because of the potential to mislead.


Obviously. Nice people by definition act nicely. It's all the rest that need the right incentives. And the nice ones also need good incentives else their niceness ejects them from the competition if the competition is set up in perverse ways.

It's like as if someone talked about tax fraud or "tax optimization" and you retorted that an upstanding business owner doesn't cheat on their taxes and even donates some extra funding towards public causes and if he makes a mistake in the taxes he quickly publicly admits it and pays the fine. But if honesty bankrupts a business, all businesses that stay alive in such an environment will be ones that do some form of tax fraud. No matter how much someone stands there wagging their finger and declaring from the cathedra what upstanding business owners do, in the abstract.


Perhaps I can educate you a little further about the academic world.

There are indeed constraints other than one's own personal or professional virtue. The principal one is that if your work does not convince your professional peers, it will not get funded or published.

You can't just invent a bogus research program out of thin air, hold a press conference, and expect to get hailed as the new Einstein.

For example: claims of cold fusion, room temperature superconductors, and similar marvels appear fairly frequently and are quickly knocked down because experts in the field can tell they are false. (NB these are not necessarily frauds, just bad science.)

There are also institutional constraints provided by the universities and professional societies to which academics belong.

Scandals about plagiarism and fraud only hit the news when these institutions take action against senior academics. This typically only happens in the worst cases where there is a clear pattern of behavior and the guardrails have obviously failed.

IMO long running and successful frauds like Cyril Burt tend to already have the benefit of a well-earned professional reputation, but have gone about boosting their credibility in an unethical way.

Small bore fraud is hard to catch. It's like padding your resume. If you say you won the Nobel prize, people will smell a rat. But a lot of it probably gets under the radar.


I've known it from the inside for quite some time. I'm not saying you'll be hailed as the next Einstein just randomly. What I wrote is much more subtle than that.


Your insights went right over my head. Perhaps you could dumb it down a bit?


You simply declared in your comment what the ideal researcher would do and how other courses of action are bad and other normative and moralizing "ought" stuff. I'm more interested in observing what people actually do in the wild, like David Attenborough. Is-ought, prescriptivism-descriptivism.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: