Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | zrn900's commentslogin

> Because they have an unelected government with no limits to the power of its leaders.

1 - Patently false, the Chinese democracy is participatory. It is called 'whole process democracy' and it's much more democratic than the popularity contests that run on a 4-year schedule in the West and produce politicians who absolutely do not keep their word

2 - There are far worse countries on this planet, including those who burn children alive on live video and they control a lot of the data in the West


Simply because the EU claims to enshrine free speech in its constitution.

EU's best recent innovation is heated car seats that require a subscription. Then it shot itself in the foot by entering a proxy war with Russia and cutting itself off from cheap energy after the US prodded it to do. Now even those subscription-heated car seats are going away as Volkswagen et al. closed all factories.

This is destructive to the civilization and it must be banned: They are literally using knowledge professions - lawyers, scientists, doctors etc - to train AI with gig work and then both causing them to get laid off and also cutting what the gig work pays.

This is literally decimating the educated workforce that human science and technology relies on. When this workforce is decimated, there won't be anyone producing the next scientific paper. Or, more likely, there will be too few. Human science and technology will get hampered as a result.


I mean... i dream of asking an AI what the code is for making home modifications, and getting a real, legally sound answer. If you ask 30 inspectors and the people who wrote the code, you'll probably get 40 answers.

I do think AI offers a solution to the misinformation problem. The problem is picking the right AI to trust. It probably needs to be open source.


Because we know China will stop with AI development as well… genie’s out of the bottle and we have to adapt

So, uh, why should knowledge professions be exempt from the same process of industrialization and proletarianization that basically all manual crafts went through in the 19th and early 20th centuries?

Was it good and for whom? Now using your own parallel how do you imagine the same will go with knowledge and with what results?

It wasn't good in the short term but in the long term average quality of life is up massively compared to 100 years ago

Will the same be true this time? Maybe...

I could certainly see AI interesting the rate of scientific breakthroughs and so leading to a technological golden age (room temperature semi conductors, cures for many diseases, quantum computing)

Or it could just lead to mass unemployment and an even bigger wealth gap

Or anything in between, I guess we'll see


> average quality of life is up massively

In what ways massively? Do you factor in negative externalities like ecosystem damage? Do you differentiate what was improved because of industralization and what would be improved regardless?


Because there's nothing left after that...

Woodchipper scene from Fargo, that describes what is happening to labor in the economy.

The US Treasury is literally manipulating money markets to force crypto exchanges to buy US Treasuries to shore up the bond market right now. They are selling everything they have to buy bonds and it's causing a crash in all markets as a result.

So no. None of those 'do this specific thing that should be sane by the science of economy' arguments work. Some powerful institution can just f*ck up your plans just because.


> Essentially all of our problems are caused by excessive population

Absolutely not. We have the technology to feed multiples of the population, house everybody, and give all modern comforts to everybody. The reason why it is not happening is that the economic system needs to induce artificial scarcity to profit.


Man... You're 22. You havent even started life yet. People are already living up to 80 years. In 1-2 generations (the 40-50s of today) will be living until 100. Your generation and later will live up to ~120 years and more. Everything will change. Your task is to survive and prosper as much as you can in the meantime.


If you think about it, telling someone who's depressed because they are not enjoying life or what it has to offer; "survive and prosper as much as you can in the meantime", simply because their generation will potentially live a lifetime longer than the current life expectancy and things are always changing, is absurd.

"Life is long", "things will get better", "you never know what will happen", "luck works in mysterious ways", and other false platitudes offered to someone deeply suffering, gives the impression that it's out of their control despite still being their responsibility. It could be read as "you have a lot longer to suffer yet and I offer no concrete reason why it shall improve, or reasons to have hope for now or that future, but trust it'll be fine". Often what follows is "if faith doesn't work then that's a sign of the sickness or your unwillingness to get better".

The chance that quick fluff like this will help someone as if they haven't thought or tried basic things like just carrying on (which they are already doing every day anyway), is near zero. Especially on such a forum (problem solvers, thinkers, higher average intelligence). Yet the chance of subtle dismissive nature of people who take time to make a fuss or signal care but not to truly understand, is extremely high. It's frequent and damaging long-term.

My suggestion would be to speak your personal experience if you have it, or spend effort to clarify and empathize how people feel. If not, it's honestly best to not say anything.


I greatly appreciate all your posts on this thread. So many people chiming in with the most jarring and condescending takes. But I can also forgive people for having never experienced severe/suicidal depression. I definitely wouldn't wish it on them. But I do wish they would shut the fuck up.


> if I get drafted, I'm waiting out for an opportunity to shoot my head

Huh?


> surrender to the other side (Russia I believe?) and spend 1-2 years [...] citizenship proceedings [...]

I almost read it as an insult, but I'll assume that you either forgot or didn't know one peculiar fact: Russian army almost never keeps their POWs alive, and even if it does, it absolutely never lets them out of the army into Russia - only back into Ukraine, through the battlefield.

this would be a valid option if I was a Russian who does not want to fight Ukraine, sure. Ukraine is ± alright with Russian POWs, partly because we have Europe watching over our shoulders. the reasoning behind your idea is sound, assuming that both sides wage an honest and Geneva-accurate war, except that Russia prefers to utilize the Genevan convention as a piece of toilet paper.

so, your idea effectively becomes suicidal, but you also get a great deal of suffering. why not cut the suffering while I can?


[flagged]


Why are you editing your comments? You are courageous enough to defend Russia, but not enough to defend your comments?


Ukraine and Russia routinely exchange POWs. This wouldn't be possible if Russia almost never kept POWs alive.

A few random recent examples from this year (but there are many others):

https://caspiannews.com/news-detail/russia-and-ukraine-swap-...

https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/russia-ukraine-swap-205...

https://english.alarabiya.net/News/world/2026/06/05/russia-u...

Correcting mistruths is not a defense of Russia's invasion of Ukraine.


You didn't see his comment, so you don't know what he was talking about. It was not a simple correction like you did


It's a cheap shot when a woman questions a mans masculinity/courage. It's deliberate and done with malice. It's like someone asking you why are you being a little bitch? Honest question.


> Why are you editing your comments?

Because I'm living in the 'democratic' West that never lies. There's freedom of speech in the West. That's why I'm editing my comments. Because in the West, you are free to say anything.


Maybe it's not your intention, but it does look like you are trying to trap people to reply and then you edit the comments to make them look unhinged


tried https://archive.org, no dice. I should develop a habit of snapshotting every reply I make.

btw, there is a Donate button. just saying :)


> (Think Oppenheimer or Bin Laden)

Lol you went from 0 to 100% really quickly there.


Hah yea odd examples, but they're the only two people I can think of who have my build. (I'm between them on height and total pounds, but that is the level of extreme skinny)


Nah man there are many people like those in Southern Europe and Western Asia. A lot of them are married. For good or bad.


> As a platform technology company why would you want these people on your board?

Investors tell you to put them on the board and you do it. The worst mistake WordPress made was taking investment from private equity and assorted Wall Street types.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: