Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's not entirely true.

Higher density means more data per track, not just more tracks per disk. You get an entire track per revolution so a track with more data is more MBps. So linear reads on a higher density drive are faster, and semi-linear accesses (ie, reading two files that are next to each other) do get faster.

I remember reading a story about a guy who built a drive array with high capacity 7200 RPM drives that got within 20% of the performance of the 10K RPM setup they had, by partitioning the drives at the same capacity as the 10K equivalent. The head only had half as many tracks to traverse, so worst case access time was better, and the higher density made up for the lower RPMs.



Short stroking helps get more performance from the disk, at least in terms of latency. The bandwidth change occurs because the density is fixed and there are more blocks on the outer rings per track compared to the inner rings so in one revolution you can read more tracks and you don't need to change tracks so often.

You parent comment is right though, there are only small changes in bit density on the track in recent years so the bandwidth is not improving by much.


So we went from 1TB to 8TB disks just by packing 3x as many tracks onto drives? I find that hard to believe, and the benchmarks agree with me.

You don't double the write throughout on a disk by doubling the number of tracks. You need more platters and/or sectors per track to do that.


> Higher density means more data per track, not just more tracks per disk.

I literally said that:

> Most density increases are achieved by packing more tracks onto the platter, while storing more sectors per track plays a minor role.


You are using a different definition of 'minor'. I don't think something that accounts for a 30-100% improvement is minor.


When capacity increased in the same time frame by 800-2000 % then I kinda call that minor.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: