Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I didn't get that from the above quote, but I haven't read Chomsky. I just have quite a bit of problems with people believing that the group is always right compared to the individual, and I got the group vibe from the above. I admit my interpretation could be in error.


No worries, I haven't read as much Chomsky as I should either.

His views are obviously nuanced, but he's most often described as an anarcho-syndiclist: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarcho_syndicalism

The main problem with your interpretation is not that the group is better than the individual, but that then the group _imposes_ that view upon the individual. There's a big difference between cooperative decision making and a dictatorship by an 'enlightened few.'


> I haven't read as much Chomsky as I should either. [emphasis added]

See?! Now they've convinced you that to be fulfilled you have to read Chomsky!


I should. I should read lots of things. Reading more is good for you.

However, in this case, what I meant was, "I really should read more Chomsky before attempting to claim that I am fully and accurately representing his viewpoint in an argument."




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: