Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> They can terminate your account suddenly for opaque reasons.

Isn't one of the requirements for being a "bank" that you can't do stuff like that?



No, not at all, banks do that too.

https://money.cnn.com/2014/05/07/pf/bank-account-closing/

I once had a bank account closed for "suspicious behavior." The suspicious behavior was making too many transfers to one of my other bank accounts.

If you open a new bank account and deposit a lot of money, say over $10,000, then they almost certainly will freeze your account and you'll have to call up to unfreeze it. Sometimes you even have to go to a branch to unfreeze it.

Chase, specifically, is really bad when you're trying to transfer to/from new accounts

https://www.doctorofcredit.com/psa-dont-use-ach-pull-for-cha...

I open (and close) a lot of bank accounts to collect those signup bonuses. If you read forums dedicated to this then you hear stories of people getting their bank accounts terminated suddenly for opaque reasons all the time.


> If you open a new bank account and deposit a lot of money, say over $10,000, then they almost certainly will freeze your account

I have done this multiple times with zero issues whatsoever. With larger sums than $10k, and with global-sized banks. Sorry to hear about your issues but you're over-extrapolating.

> I open (and close) a lot of bank accounts to collect those signup bonuses

This, I think, may be your issue. For one thing, as the recent NYT piece on customer scores shows, these companies do exchange information on their customers- you may come up flagged or even blacklisted specifically because of this


On the contrary, doing this is practically a requirement for being a bank.

US law requires banks to file a suspicious activity report if they see unusual activity in your account that may be associated with money laundering or criminal activity. What qualifies as suspicious activity is not well-defined, but can be as simple as large unexpected transfers into or out of the account.

The law also requires banks not to tell you about it. They don't necessarily have to close your account, but most will, especially after several reports, because of the risk of failing to comply in the future. And since they're not allowed to tell you why they closed the account, you end up with opaque reasons.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: