Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The arthashastra is brilliant. Much older and far more Machiavellian than Machiavelli.

Highly recommended if you are interested in ancient thought



Is the english translation good enough or reading it in Sanskrit is recommended? If yes, any translation that you recommend?


You might find my comment in this thread listing some book recommendations, useful.


Thanks for the recommendation. I was looking for something like this to add in my personal library.


You might find my comment in this thread listing some book recommendations, useful.


[flagged]


If we judge any ancient work by our current morals, we would most likely be left wanting. This book was written almost 2500 years back.


I half agree with this. IMO we should absolutely throw out content that doesn’t fit within modern morals, given our modern morals are objectively more correct and humanist than anything prior (if that is not the case we should challenge our morals not the prior text). However we can still learn from and stand to lose a great deal by destroying content with morally questionable angles.

So what we really want is an interpretation / disclaimer in front of this work that makes it clear how we should interpret it through a framework that applies today without bringing off-topic morality questions into play.


Yeah, I agree with this. The comment which I replied to which has been flagged now stated something like, "this is so misogynistic". Hence, my comment that prevailing morals were largely different then. One can choose to leave the misogynistic things yet still appreciate his work on politics and economics.


I believe in seperating people from their brilliant works. Appreciating their work/thoughts does not necessarily mean condoning their behavior. One should never accept or propagate inappropriate social cues. However, that does not mean one should lose an opportunity to be wiser by reading and assimilating thier wisdom.

As such nobody is perfect and who ever it may be, let us pick the positive qualities from them, on our way towards becoming a nicer person.


I couldn't believe it when I read it.

And they say the society in Manusmriti is much more misogynistic than this book! And this book is bad. Really bad.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: