Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not to forget the huge scam how Reliance Jio got their spectrum.

https://archive.is/Ggvmi

TLDR : that 4G spectrum auction was for Data-only. Reliance bid through a benami company, won all zones across the country, and then got the rules modified to data+voice.



I'm happy Jio did it. They singlehandedly brought about the digital transformation in India. It's truly amazing.


You're happy they did a scam , and nearly bankrupted other telcos (all their NPA will come back biting us in the form of taxes for recapitalisation )


Yes I'm happy they did this. It has benefitted me and hundreds of millions of other Indians. I remember the absolute unusable state of mobile data in the country before Jio. Now I literally don't notice if my wifi goes out, because Jio's network is so good, and they made it cheap enough for everyone to be able to afford it.

When regulation gets in the way of public good, it deserves to be circumvented. More power to Jio and Mukesh Ambani.

Edit: I don't see why telcos going bankrupt implies taxpayer bailout. If that is what will happen, it will be a fault of the government, not Jio.


Telcos going bankrupt --> their debts from banks go unpaid --> govt pays taxpayer money to keep the banks afloat. And this bankruptcy scenario caused due to fraud.

Anyways, you seem to have made up your mind that Jio fraud is good.


> govt pays taxpayer money to keep the banks afloat

This is the issue. I fail to understand how this is Jio's fault. Let the bank fail, other banks will be careful in the future.


so you are ok if someone does corruption to get the business? I really hope you live long enough to see the effects of monopoly.


Corruption in this case was justified. The rules surrounding the auction were unnecessarily prohibitive and expensive. Telcos were being forced to pay too much, which meant customers got a very expensive, limited service. Jio broke that system, by hook or by crook, and got us what we should have had long ago if markets were allowed to function naturally.

Edit: Before Jio, we had many providers, but all of them were bad for the user! I'd rather have a monopoly that works for the user over that.


What's a "benami company"?


shadow company. Benami = nameless = anonymous.


A front company.





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: