Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> lead to double taxation

I’m not sure why double taxation matters so much. If I get a salary then use some of that salary to get a haircut, the money is taxed twice but we think of this as normal.

Human W2 taxpayers are not able to write off expenses such as driving to work (or even a home office), yet these are clearly costs of doing business. Why should corporations get additional rights that aren’t afforded to humans?



Because if I'm Apple and sitting on billions of dollars I get to buy out my supply chain and I pay 0 tax for all components and transitions in the chain - and your random manufacturer X has to pay Qualcomm and gets taxed, who pays TSMC and gets taxed, who pay their suppliers and get taxed, etc. Then multiply this by every component at every step. This is a terrible incentive system for breeding huge vertically integrated monopolies even faster than we currently do.


Double taxation only matters because it complicates the tax code, there is no other justification against double taxation.

For example, if you have one tax there is only one way to optimize it, if you have two taxes there are two ways to optimize it. As you add more taxes you are adding more room for loopholes. Solving the problem by taxing profit by country is just adding more room for loop holes.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: