Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Agreed with all of this.

I'm a big fan of Blizzard products, played the original Starcraft when I was younger and still play some of the more recent games. It's blatantly obvious for a long time Blizzard has been sitting on its' laurels and not innovating.

The linked article does a great job of pointing out the major Blizzard mistakes, but I'll add one more: Blizzard's storywriting ability has fallen off a cliff. I love Blizzard games because of their great stories, but for years now the storylines have become muddled and clearly written by their D-team.

An example would be this story, but there are many more I could point to: World of Warcraft's latest cinematic is a narrative disaster and players hate it https://www.pcgamer.com/world-of-warcrafts-latest-cinematic-...



The writing in WoW nowadays truly is appalling. Playing a horde character, I spent the entire expansion forced to perform actions that made no sense internally and were the opposite of what I would have liked to do.

There is zero player agency and zero empathy. Quests were garbage and made no sense.

I’m a player who has played wow since beta sixteen years ago and I am finally at the point where I am giving up.


Fellow beta player here, I never cared about the overall story (although I like jokes and good scenes / subplots when they happen), but the design, timegating, and a large chunk of the art in SL killed the game for me. So it's really a disaster in all areas.


Blizzard writing and storytelling has always been crap. I think expectations were just lower back then.


I disagree. Both Starcraft and Diablo I had good writing.

For me the decline came with Warcraft 3. Both the visuals and story of this game were shit.

And after that WoW became juggernaut and for some reason Blizzard decided that only pre teen david Eddings fans are their audience and never bothered to check the real demographics afterwards. Such a juvenile writing could only be achieved deliberately.


I'm of the same opinion; Warcraft 3 didn't feel like a Blizzard game, and nothing has since.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: