Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Prisoners forced to choose between harsh detention or menial factory work, are not “willing”

I mean that the factories employ regular employees as well as those threatened to be sent back to detention. I don't see why both groups of people should be punished so that people thousands of miles away can feel a better conscience.

>I’m talking about the general global populace waking up to the fact that their goods are made by (essentially) slaves, as a result of labor shutdowns.

Has anything like that has ever happened in history? I don't see how people in economic distress are less likely to care about the plight of others. Meanwhile, if people cared enough to cut all trade with China, I don't see what more awareness would get us.



> I don't see why both groups of people should be punished so that people thousands of miles away can feel a better conscience.

What do you mean? This thread is about how China is violently dealing with dissenters within Asia (HK is not China). We’re talking about how a ban on slave labor Chinese goods could solve things.

> Has anything like that has ever happened in history?

Never before in history has the global manufacturing industry concentrated into one region (China).

> I don't see what more awareness would get us.

Awareness would instigate change, and China would be forced to stop utilizing prisoner-slave labor.

> people thousands of miles away can feel a better conscience

I’m really concerned by the level of dismissiveness you’re showing. Not sure if this discussion is leading anywhere.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: