Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How so ? There's a case to be made for Linear B because of the Greek Dark Ages, but Old Avestan ? By that same token, Oracle Bone Script also doesn't represent a traceable and continuous culture.


Persia was conquered by iconoclastic foreigners. Many native traditions were lost, even the knowledge of how to read the old writings. Continuity was significantly interrupted.

> There's a case to be made for Linear B because of the Greek Dark Ages

That's sufficient to defeat the claim of cultural continuity, but note also that the case that Linear B has been deciphered at all isn't on the firmest ground.


> Persia was conquered by iconoclastic foreigners.

Spouting this as if it somehow justifies or reinforces the CCP's claim to China being the oldest and therefore most venerable of cultures is just continuing to give credence to their nationalist tropes. It's not as if China had never been conquered.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: