Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not only did the reactor get shelled, and not only did I see it live, but I was so amazed at the Russians’ stupidity that I took screenshots: https://imgur.com/a/6T7p9BD

Those gigantic streaks in the lower right are shells from tanks. They certainly aren’t tracers from rifles.



A good reminder that we should all be screenshotting everything of interest, just in case it won't be believed later.


Could you elaborate why or how you determined/believe that they are tank shots, for the rest of us?


It’s easier to tell in video form. But basically you could see the shells come from the road in the distance (see the bridge?) all the way past the camera. The still frame probably makes it hard to see the scale.

You’re right to press me for details on the “tank” part. I don’t know if the shots are from tanks. But they’re so large that it rules out foot soldiers, so it’s some kind of vehicle-mounted gun.

It’s definitely not the kind of thing you want hitting a nuclear reactor.


Could also be shots from weapons mounted on armored vehicles that aren't strictly speaking tanks. Ex-Soviet mechanized forces (both sides in this fight) field a bewildering array of tracked and wheeled vehicles that look more-or-less tank-like but aren't considered tanks because they are much more lightly armored.

They're typically equipped with heavy weapons that are smaller or less powerful than tank main guns but larger than something that could readily be carried by a soldier or two.

Tank misidentification satirized here: https://twitter.com/pascalheyman/status/1088555831187128321


The reactor buildings are to the left of the camera (out of frame).


Did you confirm direction they are fired at?


Does it really matter? This is a firefight at a nuclear plant. An accident can easily gone either way.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: