That first one just sucks. I don't have anything else to say about it.
The second one is representative of the upper end of what I was getting. It's almost passable, but doesn't hold past about five seconds. The left and right half don't look like they belong to the same animal. The blank space in the middle of the face is huge and detracts from any sense of structure, and the whole mouth area is just odd.
It's seriously impressive for AI, but it's not end-of-artists type stuff. I can google "tiger black and white stencil" and get a bunch of tiger faces, and every one of them is noticeably better. People imagine there are plenty of art jobs where discrepancies like this don't matter, but there really aren't.
Yes, that tiger is shit. Here are 35 tiger stencils I generated over a few minutes with Stable Diffusion on my PC with a humble RTX 2070s gpu: https://i.imgur.com/y9oCZIz.jpg
I could run pretty much any of these through adobe illustrators auto trace and end up with an amazing vector image.
I could also leave it generating these for an hour and I'd have over 1000 results to choose from.
I do feel like you just moved the goalposts on me from AI can’t produce this style at all, to can’t produce this style on a level with an experienced human artist. I don’t think anyone is claiming it beats a good human artist. That does not make it useless for stencils.
Again those were my first try and I know nothing about stencil beyond what 2 seconds on Google images could give me. Certainly better than I could produce if you gave me Adobe Illustrator and a weekend. And the image is mine to use as I please, unlike what I could rip off Google Images.
Also, I thought the cat was cute, but there’s really no accounting for taste. Here’s a silly and swirly cat that might be more your thing? This was a cherry picked one of 10 since you have high standards;)
The second one is representative of the upper end of what I was getting. It's almost passable, but doesn't hold past about five seconds. The left and right half don't look like they belong to the same animal. The blank space in the middle of the face is huge and detracts from any sense of structure, and the whole mouth area is just odd.
It's seriously impressive for AI, but it's not end-of-artists type stuff. I can google "tiger black and white stencil" and get a bunch of tiger faces, and every one of them is noticeably better. People imagine there are plenty of art jobs where discrepancies like this don't matter, but there really aren't.