Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

An intern can only be unpaid if they are not doing productive work and you have a trainer with them. Most unpaid internships are illegal already, but the interns don't know they can/should report it.

If you are an intern in a railroad you can move cars around the yard all day: you can move them to a loading dock, or to make up a larger set for a train, but at the end of the day you must move them back. However if any of those cars are moved to the dock are loaded/unloaded, or the larger train they just made leaves the yard, then they did useful work and must be paid for that.



>>An intern can only be unpaid if they are not doing productive work and you have a trainer with them.

I mean yes, but like you yourself acknowledged - that's a completely meaningless law. No intern is going to report this, because young people are just happy to have a job, no one wants to destroy their career right at the start. I myself was in that exact same position when I started - as an intern, my contract specifically said I can't be doing any productive work. Of course I did anyway. And I'm sure it still happens in every industry, because.....why wouldn't it. That's why I think unpaid internships just shouldn't be a thing at all, anywhere, unless linked to vocational schools that oversee them as a training programme.


The more important thing is you can get the reference at the end of summer, and then turn them in when it is too late.

All unpaid internships should have regular independent auditors because, as you say, interns are unlikely to report abuse of the law.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: