Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Do you know the last successful, citizen-only driven revolution? I would guess the french revolution ~1790 and it was a bloodbath. Today, the military technology has extended the power gap so much, that chopping heads off is no option for eg. north koreans without support from the outside.

I think a violent revolution would only tighten the surveilance state.



I guess it depends on what you mean by citizen-only and successful.

How about Bolshevik? Or Cuba? Or Vietnam? Or China?

If you consider the French Revolution successful (that didn’t work out so well) then I guess you can say the Sudan revolution was successful as we now have South Sudan. Or Libya was successful as Qaddafi is still dead.


The ven diagram of people who tell me that we can't possibly overthrow the government contrasted with people who say January 6th was a threat to democracy is essentially a circle.


I don‘t think those two statements are at odds at all. Consider that the Jan 6th insurrections were trying to keep the then current president, the commander-in-chief of the armed forces, in power. That‘s about as far from a citizen‘s only revolution as it could be.


FFS, change the intent.

What is it about this topic that renders people unable to think rationally? Imagine if software was written with this quality of thinking.


> Imagine if software was written with this quality of thinking.

Windows 95 startup music plays


One difference: Windows improved.


Disagree x 2.

overthrowing the goverment via democratic means is an option too.

The circle of ppl seeing the bogaloos as idiots, preferably nowhere near any position of power is much larger.

Very distorted protortions.


We overthrow the government every two years.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: