Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>despite literally attempting a putsch

To me it never made any sense. The buffalo hat guys clearly had no greater plan, and the BBC actually had to apologize for faking a clip to make it seem Trump ordered it.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/11/13/bbc-doctored-tru...

The BBC spreads to all of the EU's other news outlets, so Europeans "know" there was a putsch attempt based on a fake clip. Literally fake news, which plays directly into Trumps narrative and adding to the teflon layer he seems covered in.

Exaggerations, bad faith reporting, assumptions of guilt based on hunches - that's counterproductive if you really want to hold power accountable.

It's very important that the accuser of a crook is not a known liar. Because then even the true accusations won't stick and the crook gets away.

 help



Your post sounds like concern trolling to me. I'm not a European and I watched the whole speech in real time and it was clear to me that he was attempting a coup.

If you think the buffalo hat guy was a coup attempt, fine - I have no interest in defending Trump.

I just wanted to highlight a common bubble-truth that turned out to not be as true as many think. You may be convinced he tried a coup, but does the BBC story perhaps move the needle a little bit towards understanding how someone else might feel that maybe he didn't?

Accusations of trolling is depressing, but I appreciate you actually writing a comment instead of just smashing the downvote.


More accurately, nothing was "faked", the footage shown was of things Trump actually said, with a lot of "weave" (aka Trump waffle) removed.

The "apology" (BBC regrets the cut was not obvious to all) included:

   “We strongly disagree there is a basis for a defamation claim.”
which is hardly the hallmark of an apology.

>nothing was "faked", the footage shown was of things Trump actually said

Of course he said the words, but not together as the sentence the BBC reported. The meaning was faked.

What the BBC did here was literally equivalent to filming someone saying "We should support Kamala and fight Trump at every opportunity" and cutting it to say "We should support Trump at every opportunity".

No honest person can accept that. No honest person can accept Trump either, for many reasons, but perhaps an actual coup-attempt is not one of those reasons.

We all live in bubbles these days, it's not easy. :-/




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: