Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It would be interesting to try to come up with some scenario that would maximize the damage caused by Fukushima, then model whether that would be a problem for any other county.

Explosion? Complete melt-down? Meteor strike? Super volcanic eruption?

Interestingly, worst-case might be to have the reactor limp along while continuing to cool it with water that's being pumped back into the ocean. Like they're doing now. Having it totally destroyed, or pushed under the sea, although perhaps creating an bad initial spike, probably wouldn't release as much radiation long-term.

This entire incident has become a test for how scientifically literate people are. And most folks aren't hitting on much.



> [...] Meteor strike? Super volcanic eruption?

Once your scenario reaches that kind of scale, I think the effect of Fukushima itself is going to be fairly negligible... :)


I think the tsunami alone was large enough that we should consider the Fukushima aftermath as negligible in comparison.


> Having it totally destroyed, or pushed under the sea, although perhaps creating an bad initial spike, probably wouldn't release as much radiation long-term.

The reactor has generated as much radioactive contamination as it's going to make (note that contamination is not the same as radiation).

So in that regard the worst numerical damage Fukushima could realistically do is to eject all of the contaimination into the sea. But even assuming that it would be of negligible impact to radiation levels ocean wide (at least, assuming adequate dispersal).

Given that it's easier to assure adequate dispersal for a continuous low-level transfer to the sea than it is to assure dispersal for effectively dropping the cores into the ocean, I think that dropping the cores into the ocean at once would actually be the worst possible thing.

Of course there are real concerns with groundwater contamination too, which might make people think that getting the damaged cores as far away as possible into the ocean is preferable. But even that possibility is more of an annoyance than a health hazard, since if the potable water going is radioactive it's easy to detect and avoid drinking it, unlike other chemical and biological drinking water hazards.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: