Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Cool. One question: what if I'm not a company?


Woo, rate limit's expired!

If you're not a company, or registered organization, or government department, you can't get an EV certificate right now. The cabforum EV guidelines [1] don't currently have provision for individuals.

I know that sucks. Especially when there is already capability to use government IDs for individuals in the EV guidelines for checking e.g. company directors in some cases [1].

But here's why:

- The certificate subject for an EV cert, i.e. the thing the CA is attesting to by signing your certificate is the unique in the jurisdiction registration ID.

Eg, visit https://github.com and click the certificate in Chrome - you can see GitHub is Delaware company 5157550.

The subject for an individual version of an EV cert would needs to be:

- unique in the jurisdiction

- publicly revealable

You couldn't use the number of the ID checked, since passport numbers, drivers license numbers and other are considered 'High Risk Confidential Information' in much of the world [2]

Unfortunately such a document don't exist in much of the world.

[1] https://cabforum.org/wp-content/uploads/EV-V1_5_61.pdf

[2] http://security.harvard.edu/book/1-high-risk-confidential-in...


The tuple (Full Name, Date of birth, Place of birth) ought to be a suitable unique subject for an individual.


"Meet my two twin sons, Collision (pronounced cole-eye-zon, we call him Cole for short) and Collision (pronounced call-iss-on, though we like to call him Colin)."


Luckily you are such a good parent that your twin sons would never dream of impersonating each other online.

And of course the Date Of Birth is really Date/Time of Birth.


The point is that "this is unique enough" is not a good standard when the data is sketchy or even subject to manipulation. The corporate ID numbers otherwise being discussed are unique by fiat.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: